🔗 Share this article

According to newly revealed information from Embark Studios, Arc Raiders appears to employ generative systems for generating some spoken content. This development is strikingly similar to the issue that arose with the developer's earlier release, The Finals.

Game Overview

Debuted on October 30th for PlayStation 5, computer platforms, and Microsoft's console, Arc Raiders is described as a more accessible entry point to the loot-and-extract category. Unlike established behemoths like Escape from Tarkov, it aims to offer a welcoming gameplay. This release has mostly received favorable reviews, currently holding a excellent score on digital distribution based on over 8,000 gamer feedback.

Technology Statement

Within the product's platform description, a notice regarding "AI Generated Content" invites parallels: In the production phase, we could utilize algorithmic and intelligent technologies to assist with asset production. In all cases, the end product reflects the artistic expression of our creative personnel."

Previous Controversy

The Finals, a successful online combat game famous for its fluid combat and destructive environments, encountered backlash for its implementation of artificial intelligence even before its public debut. In its October 2023 open beta, the project's audio lead revealed in a audio program that the company had employed artificial intelligence systems for producing vocal tracks. This statement triggered swift negative reaction from industry talent and game developers, who stated that synthetic speech were of notably lower quality compared to actor deliveries and that such methods could replace performance opportunities.

Studio Explanation

Reacting to feedback, the development team explained that they had contracted experienced talent to create initial spoken content for The Finals, but supplemented these with TTS technology to produce supplementary material based on those original recordings. The studio's rationale highlighted the production efficiency obtained via this technique.

Latest Developments

Regarding Arc Raiders, the project's design head recently stated that the release does not employ artificial intelligence creation whatsoever," though he avoided specifics on the specific interpretation of the platform statement. He did admit, however, that the identical voice system employed in The Finals was also applied in Arc Raiders.

"We use a mix of recorded voice audio and audio generated via synthetic voice systems in our games, based on the requirements," stated a development team member. In certain cases, recording real scenes where talent interacts — enabling actor relationships and drama to shape the outcome — is something that adds depth to our virtual environments that AI cannot replicate. In other instances, particularly if it involves dynamic gameplay announcements, text-to-speech enables us to have tailored VO where we otherwise wouldn't e.g. due to speed of implementation."

Gamer Feedback

Initial response to the use of AI technology in Arc Raiders has been somewhat nuanced, notably in the early days. Certain gamers have shown clear disapproval.

• Synthetic speech represents a stain on an otherwise incredible experience," commented one gamer in a forum post.
• I oppose that they implemented it in The Finals and am sad to hear they repeated it for this release," responded another.
• The result was immediately noticeable in the dialogue delivery for one protagonist," mentioned a third player.

However, some users have expressed a more accepting stance.

• I don't care, they compensated performers and used it well," stated one community member.
• "This is as ethical as it is possible nowadays, I'm afraid," continued another.

The ongoing controversy about artificial intelligence use in game development seems likely to continue as developers juggle development pace with artistic integrity and ethical considerations.